Will Transvaginal Mesh and Bladder Slings be Recalled From the Market?



A number of health experts and consumer protection groups have called for a recall of transvaginal mesh and bladder sling products designed to treat pelvic organ prolapse (POP) and stress urinary incontinence (SUI), due to the risk of serious and debilitating complications.

Despite tens of thousands of reports involving injuries, it does not appear that the FDA will be issuing a surgical mesh recall.

Rather than removing the products from the market, the agency announced in April 2014 that it was reclassifying the mesh as a high-risk medical device, which will require manufacturers to conduct rigorous pre-market studies before introducing new products.

Studies May Determine Whether Recall Is Issued

In July 2011, the FDA issued a warning about the risk of bladder sling and surgical mesh complications, including:

  • Erosion Into The Vagina
  • Infections
  • Organ Perforation
  • Return of Urinary Problems

The FDA has indicated that it appears that there is no benefit to having a transvaginal mesh implant when compared to more traditional ways of treating POP. While the safety review is still ongoing, FDA officials have indicated that the agency is having trouble finding a reason that these dangerous products should continue to be used, and many doctors have stopped implanting the products.

In January 2012, the FDA told all transvaginal mesh manufacturers that it would require new postmarketing studies and clinical trials on vaginal mesh products in order to help determine if they are a health threat or whether they have any actual benefits.

Shortly after the announcement, Ethicon withdrew several of its transvaginal mesh products from the market, including the Prolift, Prolift+M, Prosima and TVT Secur. Ethicon specifically asked that the withdrawal allow them to avoid being part of the agency’s efforts to answer questions as to whether the products were safe for women.

C.R. Bard has also removed the Avaulta pelvic mesh from the market for the same reasons, citing a desire to avoid the clinical trials, which could shed light on problems inherent with all vaginal mesh products.

In April 2014, the FDA finally took steps to address the risk of surgical mesh problems and prevent manufacturers from introducing products under the controversial 510k fast-track approval process, where new medical devices are allowed onto the market as long as they are “substantially equivalent” to another previously approved device.

Lawsuits Over Failure to Recall Vaginal Mesh Products

Consumers have raised valid questions about why these studies were not required before the products were introduced, and how the vaginal mesh has not been recalled until the products are determined to be safe and effective.

Thousands of women throughout the United States are now pursuing a vaginal mesh or bladder sling lawsuit, alleging that the manufacturers placed their desire for profits before consumer safety my not fully studying the surgical mesh products, warning about the risk of problems or issuing a surgical mesh recall as soon as it became apparent that the products carry substantial risks and may provide no benefits over alternative treatments.

The transvaginal mesh lawyers at Saiontz & Kirk, P.A. are reviewing individual lawsuits by women who suffered severe complications after being implanted with a transvaginal mesh. All claims are handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning there are no out-of-pocket expenses. The product liability lawyers at Saiontz & Kirk, P.A. are only paid if a recovery is obtained.

If you, a friend or family member has suffered complications due to a vaginal mesh implant, you could be entitled to compensation through a bladder sling lawsuit. Request a free consultation and claim evaluation.

Austin Kirk

Last Updated December 11, 2012

2 Comments • Add Your Comments

  • marie says:

    I had a mesh surgery 12/12 and had complications 2 days later, Infection that was ignored although I was in the surgeons office on Monday morning. I’m an RN and well aware of signs/symptoms of infection. On new years 2013 I was in the hospital on IV antiboitics for “cellulitis” in February I was in the hospital X 6 days on 5 different antibiotics and had to be taken to the OR for excision of a 12x2cm abscess that had to be left open and irrigated daily and packed with nugauze daily. I did all of this myself ,I was extremely painful and difficult to look at.
    Although I SPECIFICALLY asked my female gynecologist” does the mesh you use have anything to do with the the any of the ones I’m seeing on television commercials” her response” absolutely not” well it absolutely was (Monroe) I’m stupid I should have done research but I believed her being nieve and who would knowingly do that to someone.
    I am unable to have any form of vaginal penetration due to tremendous pain and the crazy thing is I had the surgery to improve our sexual relationship because I always felt I would urinate during intercourse and although we’ve been married 26 years I was embarrassed.
    She never said anything to me about about the sexual complications that could occur and only discussed the complications of anesthesia and infection. When I read my records she notes that she said to me” anyone who wants to have vaginal sex should not have this surgery”
    Ya I saw a lawyer band after they take there share I got 12 thousand dollars!
    I’ve tried to let the pain anger and actual hate for her go and thought I did until now that I’m writing this I realize I havent.
    I’m looking for information now because I’m experiencing more complications and don’t know where to turn.who can you trust the lawyers and manufacturers of these torture devices have set up a payment system according to what they’ve agreed on and we the victims Women are out of the loop. These companies have made $$$$ and now the lawyers are with these class action suits we women are left destroyed and mamed.
    Had this been an issue related to a man’s PENIS the outcome would have been much different. I send prayers and healing to all the women out there dealing with any and all issues physical and emotional related to this situation and pray that your able to move foreword despite what’s happened to your body you are still BEAUTIFUL!

    Posted on December 4, 2015 at 9:30 am

  • marie says:

    I had mesh surgery in 2008. I have been bleeding almost ever since. Infections has affected my bowels, bladder, pain no intercourse to painful and now the doctor what’s to cut the bladder sling. Filed law suit but I don’t believe I would get squat for all the suffering after the attorney’s taking


    Posted on February 24, 2016 at 3:16 pm

Add Your Comments

  • Have Your Comments Reviewed by a Lawyer

    Provide contact information below and additional private comments if you want an attorney to contact you to review a potential case.

    The information below will not be published to this page.

  • NOTE: Providing information for review by an attorney does not form an attorney-client relationship.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.